Trade Evaluation

Discussion in 'Fantasy Football Advice' started by SlipoftheKnife, Oct 6, 2015.

  1. SlipoftheKnife

    SlipoftheKnife DP 2018 Week 2 expire Premium Member

    Big League Trade - Current QB Tannehill and Roethlisberger

    I give Moncrief and I get Eli Manning

    Small League - Current QB Phillip Rivers and no backup

    I give Doug Martin and Marvin Jones I get Eli Manning

    I like Manning's schedule. He's playing a lot of crap defenses I think and would be a worthy QB1 that I'm getting for a steal. Maybe I'm wrong?
     
  2. LebaneseFF

    LebaneseFF Error loading Staff Member Premium Member Fantasy Guru

    good trades for both teams, i like your first one better. Moncrief with gurley becomes expandable
     
  3. SlipoftheKnife

    SlipoftheKnife DP 2018 Week 2 expire Premium Member

    Moncrief with Gurley becomes expandable? What do ya mean? I'd be losing Moncrief for Manning
     
  4. LebaneseFF

    LebaneseFF Error loading Staff Member Premium Member Fantasy Guru

    Sorry I wrote that on my phone. I hate responding on my phone.

    I think it was a good trade because you are losing Moncrief but that is okay because you will probably start Gurley from here on out.
     
  5. PeteTheGreek

    PeteTheGreek Super Moderator Staff Member Fantasy Guru

    I disagree with both trades but I really do not value QBs. Unless it's a 6pt pass TD or 2-QB league, I will never trade a quality position player for a QB. So, you have two differing opinions here, but I would not do it.
     
  6. SlipoftheKnife

    SlipoftheKnife DP 2018 Week 2 expire Premium Member

    It is a 6 point per TD league for both leagues. Eli's schedule is what appeals to me the most. The Giants go up against a whack ass defenses