Patriots Vs Giants (Super Bowl XLVI Gameday Thread)

FALSE. Peyton is in the discussion of greatest QB EVER. Eli may be ONE OF the better QB's in the NFL today but he is no Peyton. When he puts up Peyton numbers during the season I'll entertain it. He's not anywhere close yet.

 

For those Star Wars Fans...

 

Two rings? I'd say you'd have to start giving the conversation some merit. I'd like to see a couple seasons like he had this year to put Eli over Peyton. That's IF he wins.

 

Giants punt again.

 

This.

But, don't tell Giants fans that.

 

Patriots didn't break on defense. Time for Brady & Co. to do their thing.

 

Coke orgy? That's how I interpret this commercial.

And let's see how Tom Terrific responds to this one.

 

JPP with another blocked pbutt.

 

ANOTHER batted down pass

 

:withstupid:

 

Wow, JUST short of the first there. That hurt.

 

So you're saying that Eli is better than Dan Marino and Jim Kelly?

 

IF he wins. Let me be more clear.

 

Disagree about SBs making QBs elite.

I give you Terry Bradshaw. Your move.

 

I can guarantee if Eli does get a 2nd ring tonight, that conversation will be started. In fact, I've already seen the sports media stoking those flames. To me, it is that never ending argument that neither side can truly win. Stats versus wins. Quarterbacks don't operate in a vacuum. They are not solely responsible for their team's wins and losses. Otherwise I guess you would have to say guys like Trent Dilfer and Brad Johnson are better than Dan Marino or Jim Kelly. Which no, I'm not even remotely prepared to make that argument. lol

I think who wins this argument just depends on who you ask. I'd never expect a universal "correct" opinion on it.

 

Welkers mustache is AWESOME!

 

Sorry but peyton never had a defense like the giants.

Droid x. 49ers

 

Marino...no.

Kelly...he's in the conversation easily...