Who is the better QB? Manning or Brady?

Manning is a better QB than Brady. The "better talent" that Brady had around him for most of those years was called a defense. I'd like to see what Brady would do if he was released and signed with a team that was 8-8 the previous year. Say a team like the Dolphins. Would he have similar Manning-type success?

 

Jake Plummer

I defy anyone to try and explain how he isnt superior to both

 

*crickets

 

If you're solely judging h2h, Brady leads 10-4.

 

what does H2H really prove ? not like they are on the field at the same time.

 

Disagree.

 

Wtf? Are you really stupid? You disagree that manning and Brady aren't on the field at the same time? I must have missed Manning's snaps at linebacker against the Patriots

 

Did I just witness two Cowboys fans say Joe is the best?

 

What I meant was I think that h2h is a way to gauge who is the better QB.

 

Well that's what happens when you make one word posts and can't explain yourself. People assume you're an idiot.

 

would'nt it be ironic if they both made it to the hall of fame at the same time?

 

But it isn't. The rest of their teams makes a huge difference, obviously.

 

I'd find it more fitting than ironic.

 

I don't think it'll happen. At this point, I see Brady playing a little longer than manning.

 

Since Ragman thinks they both play defense, I think both their careers end on a play where Peyton crushes Brady.

 

I wonder if the broncos win the super bowl this year if manning walks away and retires?

 

He has to take a physical after the year is done to check on his neck. I've heard he'll decide his future based on that.

 

@JJ, Dawk, and Steve: I find these comments that you made to me totally STUPID because I've been watching football long before your parents committed the monumental sin of having the three of you. The three of you better hope that profanity doesn't come back to GIF. If it does, I'm taking all 3 of you to the FC. When I'm done, you'll look like pieces of hamburger meat.

 

Let's stick to the topic at hand...

 

Dude, Dawkins is like 64.