Is Dawkins A Hall Of Fame Saftey

When dawkins retires will he go into the hall of fame? I was talking to ktrain about it and he doesent thinks so. And he also thinks polamalu is way better than dawkins.

 

I think he'll make it.

First ballot? Prolly not.

 

yeah and i freaking hate everything about polamalu....and the argument was 05 polamalu who was one of the very best before he went all gay and got his money.

edit....god damnit lol, freaking coding error...that was quality crap there too

 

not until jack tatum makes it

 

Ok its 2-2 come on people vote.

 

IMO, you gotta be smoking some crack to not think so and I'm far from an Eagles fan.

 

So we have 2 crack-smokers then... I have my suspicions...

 

Yea thats why i made the thread cause of coarse im going to say he will. Ive never seen a player with the same intensity during a game as brian dawkins.

 

With some of these posts around here wasn't it obvious? :icon_smile:

 

here was our conversation

dawkins>>>>>>>>>>polamalu any time
ask anyone
no freaking way
dawkins is the best

now focus on that last line....dawkins is the best

this is typical bitb....Dawkins is the best, trotter was the best, kearse was the best, TO was the best, stallworth was the best, the eagles draft was the best, the eagles oline is the best, booker is the best backup...he didnt know who booker was until the draft day trade. Curtis is the best #2 wr ever And mcnabb is the unquestioned best ever....EVEN THOUGH he not only wanted him benched last year...he changed his fantasy football teams name to "trade mcnabb i hate him bring in kolb".

You flip flop way to much

then he says.

Dawkins is the best of the best.

meaning the best to ever grace the position.

By no means am i defending troy at all, just the very thought makes me sick but for a while even i considered troy to be one of the best, just behind ed reed....obviously hes taken that in a different direction with the gayness and all but whatever. I dont think hes a hall of famer, because i think the hall of fame is for the best of the best and not the just good.

and put that heart and passion crap away, they use that for jack lambert all the time and its goobered. you cant measure leadership or heart and bad players have heart and passion too.

take those green freaking shades off just for a few minutes....im telling you it might be relieving to not be all over every single players rod all at once

 

I might be a little biased since he's my favorite player of all time... but I'd say yes.

 

both of them came up in our little discussion...it was no use though lol

 

I just think he's a HOF. I agree with most of what K Train posts.

 

lol yea i say certain players are the best cause i love my team but dawkins is totally different. I actually believe Brian dawkins is one of the best. He has had a great career consistently and should be put up there with the best. He only had 2 years that were bad last year being one of them. Nobody plays with the intensity of brian dawkins. He has produced great numbers for 15 years there is no doubt in my mind hes a hall of famer. Also when i mentioned that you said polamalu is better than dawkins you agreed. You mentioned his 05 season which is one season big deal. Dawkins has had better seasons than that and consistently. You said yourself that polamalu is a fairy now so that one season doesent prove anything. One season shouldent be how you judge whos better. I judge players by whos had the most successfull career and dawkins has had a damn good one.

 

Right... and they are two of of the top 5 safeties in the history of the game. Who either are or will be in the hall of fame.

I don't understand the point you were trying to make.

 

Yes, but not first ballot.

 

You been hittin' the sauce???

 

Just because they were better doesent make him any less deserveing of the hall of fame.