Who Should Be The NFL Offensive Rookie Of The Year?

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9z6AMlmA65w]Debate: Rookie of the Year - YouTube[/ame]

​

 

the thing is, all 3 of the qb's may make the playoffs ............. luck has probably done more with less talent around him so i'll take him.

 

I agree with your justification. He does have a crap-ton more INTs than the other two though.

 

Luck has more on his shoulders, is asked to do more with way less, and has the most pressure on him. He's bound to make mistakes. I'd take him over the other two 100 times out of 100.

 

Luck. I'd love, love, LOVE to see Wilson win it based on the fact that he too went to a crapty team...difference being, everyone expected this kind of "talent" out of Luck and Griffin. Not many expected Wilson to play at the level he is playing.

 

Russell Wilson scares the hell out of me. The guy is really good. I am shocked to see him playing this well this quick into his career. I kind of expected Luck to be good and RG3 is much better than I thought he would be. All 3 are deserving of the award.

 

I've been the most impressed with RG3 honestly. Every throw is on the money.

 

BTW, poll's working again.

 

Screwed up thing is there wasn't one reason to doubt him, yet everyone put so much of an emphasis on him not being tall enough. Kid had an excellent college career. Really glad to see him doing exceptionally well.

His numbers would probably be a lot better had Carroll been running this offense a lot closer to the start of the season.

 

It's gotta be RG3 man, kids been playing out of his mind this entire season. Remember what we were all saying in the beginning of the season "this kids gonna get killed, he's gonna get crushed." not because he's bad simply because he really doesn't have a whole lot around him either.

 

I went with RGIII, but what an insane rookie class of QBs.

 

The fact that Griffen has missed games won't hurt him? Or how well the team has played with him out?

 

Rg3 without a doubt crap it could even could be alfred morris he has a crapton of yards

 

i vote luck, it will either be luck or RG3 for sure but id vote luck.

Richardson>Martin imo though....richardson might not have the YPC but he has injected life into the browns and loves the endzone

 

RgIII. Where did the "Luck is doing more with less" thing come from? Luck had, and leaned on heavily, the best vet WR in the game today, and a very talented supporting.cast. RGIII has Pierre Garcon and Logan Paulsen.

 

http://www.nfl.com/stats/categoryst..._YARDS_PER_GAME_AVG&d-447263-o=2&d-447263-n=1

 

It's kind of a shame they do these and don't include the playoffs...

 

I could see Seattle winning a couple games in the playoffs, the Redskins not making it at all and the Colts losing in the first round...then what?