Dante Hall Or Devin Hester

Ok so I'm having a conversation with a friend of mine. Basically arguing between Dante Hall and Devin Hester. Who's the better return man?

 

Hester

 

dante hall isn't in the league so hester wins by default.

 

Hall was better for a shorter period of time.

 

And the winner of funniest post of the year goes to...

Longevity plays a big part of greatness. Hester has been the best return guy since he came into the league, except for last year. Hall was amazing for like 2 maybe 3 years, but then sputtered out.

 

did either win a superbowl? if not, they both suck.

 

Hester may have had more return touchdowns than Hall, but I'd rather watch Dante Hall return it over Hester any day of the week. XO

 

That's flawed logic.

 

Worse than that, it's a bad joke.

 

its hester, its not really that close

 

^^ This. There's probably quite a few between Hester and Hall.

 

That's what I've been trying to tell him. I think it just makes him feel smart saying the lesser known player is better. The casual fan more than likely doesn't know who Hall is, so they can't call him on it. But I do, so I did, and he won't listen.

 

Don't get me wrong Hall was amazing, but Hester has been amazing for a much longer period of time

 

if a kick returner is gonna make the hall ever it would be hester as of now. Obviously someone could overtake that still this generation, but for now its hester

 

Wasn't it Dante Hall that did that sick butt "backward juke" on the sideline? Anyone remember what I'm talking about?
[MENTION=4046]ICECOLD[/MENTION] said exactly what I told the guy. I'm not arguing against Hall being an all time great returner, but his greatness was too short lived. Although his highlight reel might be the best ever.

 

Here it is. This is sick.

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQcqZD6OMOM]Dante Hall sickest juke ever - YouTube[/ame]

 

[ame=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lQcqZD6OMOM]Dante Hall sickest juke ever - YouTube[/ame]

this one? damn that's just ridiculous lol

 

That is insane for real. Idk if that has even been topped to this day. I can watch that over and over.

 

It's Hester and your friend needs a good smack to get back to reality. Enjoy handing down the sentence!

[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HuCMb9FYyDA"]Devin Hester All 19 returns through 11-14-2011 - YouTube[/ame]

 

Hester, free & clear...

Then you need to beat him till he agrees.