NFL Quarterback Game

Discussion in 'NFL General Discussion' started by ravenfan52, Apr 25, 2008.

  1. ravenfan52

    ravenfan52 Perennial All Pro

    This game seems sort of complicated, but once you catch on, it's actually really easy. I sort of stole this from another site, but I thought we should try it out here. So here's the way this game works. One quarterback per team. Each quarterback starts out with 20 points. Every person copies and pastes the list of quarterbacks into their post and can add 2 points and subtract 1 point from quarterbacks. So for example, if your two favorite teams are the Jaguars and the Redskins, you could add 1 point for Jason Campbell and 1 point for David Garrard. If you're least favorite teams are the Cowboys and Colts, you could subtract 1 point from either Peyton Manning OR Tony Romo. NOT both. If you like the Jaguars a little bit more than the Redskins, you could add 2 points to Garrard, but none to Campbell. So you have two points to add and one to subtract each turn. YOU MAY NOT POST MORE OFTEN THAN ONCE EVERY 6 HOURS. A quarterback is eliminated once he hits 0. When you go, please change the number ("David Garrard - 22"), and then at the top or bottom, indicate what you did [David Garrard +2 (Enter) Peyton Manning -1]. Also, please bold your move. I've estimated the starting quarterback for each team. Sometimes it was hard, but I did my best. I've ordered the quarterbacks by division. If a quarterback is eliminated, follow the following format:

    Eliminated:
    (quarterback's name) - (name of person who eliminated them)

    So if Ben Roethlisberger has 1 point left, and I subtract 1 from him, I would put this in the eliminated list:

    Eliminated:
    Ben Roethlisberger - ravenfan52

    If anyone has any questions or is confused, just ask me and I'll clarify. Also, please tell me if you think that a team's starting quarterback should be different. I'll go first and hopefully you'll catch on.
    I've put what the first poster should copy and paste in quotes (unbold Boller and Roethlisberger). I almost forgot, reorder them from first to last.
    Here's my first turn:

    Kyle Boller +2
    Ben Roethlisberger -1

    "Kyle Boller - 22
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Tom Brady - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Josh McCown - 20
    Peyton Manning - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    JaMarcus Russell - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 20
    Eli Manning - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20
    Ben Roethlisberger - 19

    Eliminated:"
     
  2. Dougerrrr

    Dougerrrr Laus Deo

    Ben Roethlisberger +2
    Kyle Boller -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-21
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Tom Brady - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Josh McCown - 20
    Peyton Manning - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    JaMarcus Russell - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 20
    Eli Manning - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20


    Eliminated:"
     
  3. Ridin Burgundy

    Ridin Burgundy on the Magic Bandwagon

    The only problem I have with these is that the player that wins will just be from the most supported on this site so you could get someone like Alex Smih winning it.
     
  4. mike oxlong

    mike oxlong The Voice Of Reason

    not if people are really serious about the response
     
  5. dolphindude13

    dolphindude13 Jack Of All Trades

    Josh McCown +2
    Tom Brady -1

    Josh McCown - 22
    Ben Roethlisberger-21
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    JaMarcus Russell - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 20
    Eli Manning - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20
    Tom Brady - 19
     
  6. TJ

    TJ Dez Caught It

    Tony Romo +2
    Donovan McNabb -1
     
  7. Sportsguy

    Sportsguy AKA-Sportsguy9695

    +2 Peyton Manning
    -1 Tony Romo

    Josh McCown - 22
    Ben Roethlisberger-21
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 22
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    JaMarcus Russell - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 19
    Eli Manning - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20
    Tom Brady - 19
     
  8. Ridin Burgundy

    Ridin Burgundy on the Magic Bandwagon

    But its already started with Boller +2:icon_eek:

    He won't even be playing.
     
  9. 86WARD

    86WARD -

    Ben Roethlisberger +2
    Tom Brady -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-23
    Josh McCown - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 22
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    JaMarcus Russell - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 19
    Eli Manning - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20
    Tom Brady - 18
     
  10. nastynate184

    nastynate184 Fuck Michigan

    JaMarcus Russel +2
    Tom Brady -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-23
    Josh McCown - 22
    JaMarcus Russell - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 22
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 19
    Eli Manning - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20
    Tom Brady - 17
     
  11. Sportsguy

    Sportsguy AKA-Sportsguy9695

    +2 Eli Manning
    -1 Tony Romo

    Ben Roethlisberger-23
    Josh McCown - 22
    JaMarcus Russell - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 22
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 18
    Eli Manning - 22
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 20
    Tom Brady - 17
     
  12. +2 Marc Bulger
    -1 Matt Hasselbeck

    Ben Roethlisberger-23
    Josh McCown - 22
    JaMarcus Russell - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 22
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 18
    Eli Manning - 22
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Tom Brady - 17
     
  13. 86WARD

    86WARD -

    Big Ben +2
    Brady -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-25
    Josh McCown - 22
    JaMarcus Russell - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    Peyton Manning - 22
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Tony Romo - 18
    Eli Manning - 22
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Tom Brady - 16
     
  14. I forsee this game coming down to McNabb and Big Ben just because of the plethora of steeler/eagles fans here lol
     
  15. nastynate184

    nastynate184 Fuck Michigan

    JaMarcus Russell +2
    Tom Brady -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-25
    JaMarcus Russell - 24
    Josh McCown - 22
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Peyton Manning - 22
    Eli Manning - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Tony Romo - 18
    Tom Brady - 15
     
  16. Marion Who?

    Marion Who? Captain Stiff Arm

    Tony Romo +2
    Tom Brady -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-25
    JaMarcus Russell - 24
    Josh McCown - 22
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Peyton Manning - 22
    Eli Manning - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 20
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 20
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Tony Romo - 20
    Tom Brady - 14
     
  17. jkrhomies8

    jkrhomies8 Starter

    Jake Delhomme- +2
    Tom Brady- -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-25
    JaMarcus Russell - 24
    Josh McCown - 22
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Peyton Manning - 22
    Eli Manning - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 22
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 22
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Tony Romo - 20
    Tom Brady - 13
     
  18. nastynate184

    nastynate184 Fuck Michigan

    quick everyone pile on brady
     
  19. Marion Who?

    Marion Who? Captain Stiff Arm

    I've done my 6 Hours. :icon_cool:

    Tony Romo +2
    Tom Brady -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-25
    JaMarcus Russell - 24
    Josh McCown - 22
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Peyton Manning - 22
    Eli Manning - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 22
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 22
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Tony Romo - 22
    Tom Brady - 12
     
  20. 86WARD

    86WARD -

    BR +2
    TB -1

    Ben Roethlisberger-27
    JaMarcus Russell - 24
    Josh McCown - 22
    Marc Bulger - 22
    Peyton Manning - 22
    Eli Manning - 22
    Kyle Boller - 21
    Derek Anderson - 20
    Carson Palmer - 20
    Trent Edwards - 20
    Kellen Clemens - 20
    David Garrard - 20
    Vince Young - 20
    Matt Schaub - 20
    Philip Rivers - 20
    Jay Cutler - 20
    Brodie Croyle - 20
    Aaron Rodgers - 20
    Tarvaris Jackson - 20
    Jon Kitna - 20
    Rex Grossman - 20
    Jason Campbell - 20
    Donovan McNabb - 20
    Jeff Garcia - 20
    Jake Delhomme - 22
    Drew Brees - 20
    Chris Redman - 22
    Matt Leinart - 20
    Shaun Hill - 20
    Matt Hasselbeck - 19
    Tony Romo - 22
    Tom Brady - 11