Non-Winning Super Bowl QBs : Who Are You Taking?

Say you're not happy with your current QB...maybe you are, what QB, that has NOT won a Super Bowl are you taking to lead your team? Maybe it's your current guy, maybe you'd like someone else?

Discuss...

 

Stafford, again, and its not even close lol

id rank them:

Stafford
Rivers
Cutler
and i think id still take marino over some of the guys left lol

 

I think I'd go Rivers first and then Cutler, followed be Stafford. I'd like to see another good season out of Stafford...if we see the Staffird of last year on a consistent basis, IMO, it's not close...

 

Always thought a change of scene would do wonders for Rivers. Id take him first then a toss up between Schaub *granted he stays healthy, not happening obviously* or Cutler

 

Rivers. A former San Diego boy already came and did it big with my team (and needs to stay), but if I had to choose. Rivers.

 

Stafford by far. I think I might take cutler over rivers.

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S2 Skyrocket

 

I think rivers would do amazing as a eagle

 

I'll take Marino.

 

Rivers or Stafford.

I like Schaub but he is hurt too often

 

Youth is what I'd be looking for first. If I am taking someone, it's not going to be someone on the wrong side of 30. I want a cornerstone QB I can build a team around. So I'd pick Stafford. The only knock on Stafford is that he's injury prone (although last year he finally remained healthy for the first time in his career). I am surprised nobody has mention Cam Newton yet. The weapons he brings are unique and he opened up my eyes with his passing. He did complete 60% of his passes and throw for over 4K. Cut down on the INT's and work on the accuracy more and he's in the mix.

 

id roll the dice with luck over cam personally

 

vince young - ftw !

seriously though i'd take stafford in a heartbeat followed by rivers. to me cutler already showed enough reason to stay away from him.

 

I am partial to our qb. But if he was not available then I would pick Andy Dalton.

 

Dalton...

Interesting pick.

 

I think he is a cool customer. Has a decent arm, not overly powerful. Makes good decisions. Just hope they continue to surround him with talent.

 

im weve already seen the best of andy dalton, hes not exactly a high ceiling type guy but a guy who might be able to get it done with safe consistency

 

Andy Dalton was pretty bad vs good defenses last year. The only decent defense he played well against was Cleveland, but they can't score enough to matter.

I like Dalton, I had him as the 3rd best QB coming out in 2011, but if I'm trying to win a Super Bowl now, it's Matthew Stafford all day, followed by pecker-head Philip Rivers, and then maybe rod-head Jay Cutler. I seriously despise Rivers and Cutler, but they know how to throw a football.

 

Dalton is an interesting pick. I think he could do well in New Orleans ( not that i'd EVER give up Brees for him ). But, Luck .. i'd have to see how he does this season, first. He was good at Stanford. He's smart. He makes plays. But this is a different level. Let's see how he reacts. Though, I'd probably go with him over Cam, either way. I just don't think Cam will be that superman QB for long. People will figure him out, they will tear him apart. I may take Tebow over Cam at this point..for the simple fact Tebow has heart. He's a winner.

 

Wow, you'd take Tebow over Newton!?!? Not me.

Tebow may have all the heart in the world, but he throws like a woman. He's no NFL QB.

 

Cam is overrated, IMO. He had a good year rookie-stat wise. Doesn't make him a world beater. I just think if Tebow gets the coaching and work he needs that he can be an NFL QB. People are so quick to write him off because of his athletic ability and his throwing motions. He thrives off that hate that people tell him he cannot do it. Cam is just arrogant, and believes he is better than he is. Problem is, the media believes it, too.