Please Don't Kill Me For Making This Thread But

Discussion in 'San Francisco 49ers' started by TDJets72027, Nov 14, 2007.

  1. TDJets72027

    TDJets72027 Rex Ryan baby

    Is Alex Smith a bigger bust than Akili Smith?
  2. DaBearsrule4ever

    DaBearsrule4ever Hall Of Famer

    I'm gonna leave this thread alone. I can't wait to read Barl's response.
  3. Spiderman34

    Spiderman34 Starter

    I'd say maybe more Joey Harringtonish.
  4. BarlOwens

    BarlOwens Rubicon Runner

    Do you moonlight as a nut scrubber at an all male veterans home?

    Weren't you the one claiming he was going to throw for 4k yards before the season?

    and if your going to pick a person to compare him need to use my scale of...1 to Ryan Leaf...

    He ranks a 1.5 in my book...cuz at least Ryan Leaf recognized how badly he sucks and started coaching high school golf...Sure he picks up on all the teenage poon....he may be a bust, but he uses the bust better than most...
  5. TDJets72027

    TDJets72027 Rex Ryan baby

    I was defending Alex Smith, but I can't defend him no mo. He is garbage.
  6. TJ

    TJ Dez Caught It

    And that's why you NEVER give a $50M contract to a kid who has never taken a snap in the pros...
  7. skinsfan1

    skinsfan1 BANNED

    He is a huge BUST. what a waste.
  8. ollysj

    ollysj iKraut

    lol, Akili Smith was here with the Galaxy and sucks crap. On the other hand, Alex Smith denied to come to Europe, bc it was so important to be with the team and learn the plays. Finally he will disappear like Akili and Ryan Leaf did, or he will be a 3th string on a crappy team.
  9. Jammin Jaguar

    Jammin Jaguar English Student.

    LMAO at Barl's response, but I agree with him, Alex Smith needs to notice he sucks and move on.

    He will never accomplish anything worth his contract.
  10. Greg Brosh

    Greg Brosh Local Eagles Fan Fantasy Guru

    Hypathetical question:

    If Norv Turner was still the OC in San Fran, would Smith and the offense as a whole be as bad as it is now?
  11. BarlOwens

    BarlOwens Rubicon Runner

    no....Turner is a great offensive mind..he's just not a good head coach...he was able to mask a lot of the problems the niners had...namely Smith's inability to progress through more than 1-2 receivers..and to keep Smith on the move to avoid dealing with his poor pocket awareness..
  12. 49ers121

    49ers121 Portugal Mike

    Smith doesnt go through the progresions like most QB's do and he constantly locks on one reciever when he's going to throw the ball. I'm tired of the excuses people make for this guy.
  13. BarlOwens

    BarlOwens Rubicon Runner

    get used to it...there are always apologists out there...and the homers are steadfast..
  14. andy82

    andy82 Your Soul, It's Mine!

    Was looking decent last season with Norv Turner but hen as an OC he can make any QB look good (Heavy Emphasis on the OC bit).
  15. joemontana25

    joemontana25 Rookie

    No, for sure.

    Even if A Smith is struggling week after week this year, this is not his entiere fault:
    We have the worst OC of the league :word04:
    The OL sucks badly
    our WR have hands of stone
    DJAX <<< Antonio Bryant