Worse QB?

Discussion in 'San Francisco 49ers' started by Fez, Oct 19, 2008.


Worse QB?

  1. Alex Smith

  2. JT O'Sullivan

  1. Fez

    Fez Chicharooney!!!

    It's a poll. A similar one was posted on .com, but for the sake of my mental health, I want to hear opinions from people whose opinions I actually respect and care about.

    Simple question, who's been the worse QB between Alex Smith and JT O'Sullivan? Please vote, niner and non-niner fans.
  2. TJ

    TJ Dez Caught It

    Does it really matter? Both of them suck...but one of them isn't raping the franchise with that $50 million contract.
  3. dolphindude13

    dolphindude13 Jack Of All Trades

    Exactly, I voted Smith just because of what he has and is costing them.
  4. Roy31

    Roy31 Hall Of Famer

    JT gets my voted, I really haven't seen anything from him. But on the other hand I haven't seen Smith do much since his days at Utah.
  5. ronbart

    ronbart Pro Bowler

    if only there was a third choice:

    "they both suck equally as football players, but one costs more, and i dont even know how the other got a job"

    cause thats what i would vote for
  6. Jihad Joe

    Jihad Joe Life to Infidels

    If Turner was still there, Smith could have been a Pro Bowler

    His problem is that he needs a top OC, and one willing to completely scheme to his strengths
  7. Dunn

    Dunn Starter

    I went Smith hands down
  8. bullnutz

    bullnutz Rookie

    Which strengths are you referring to??

    Is it his uncanny ability to hold onto the ball until he's forced to scramble and throw it away??

    Or could it be his ability to stare down his reciever until he's forced to throw it away??

    Or is it his ability to scramble away from pressure before he throws it away??

    Or possibly his ability to find the open reciever THEN throw it away??
  9. Crowned

    Crowned Doesn't give a shit.

    I still believe in Alex Smith, Dunno why honestly.
  10. Platoon 86

    Platoon 86 Loony

    Alex. J.T. can make some nice passes occasionally, although he's nothing special either.
  11. linz_renee

    linz_renee Well-Known

    I think JT is better right now. Smith needs some 2nd stringer time under someone good.
  12. Walnuts

    Walnuts All-Pro


    Alex never, even with Turner there, looked like anything approaching an NFL caliber starting qb. JTO, in between his numerous turnovers, does. It's not even close.
  13. SuperBeast

    SuperBeast BANNED

    In a half season with the 9ers Sully did things Smith couldn't. The only downside to Sully is his turnovers and Smith has the same problem, maybe even worse...

    JTO is the better qb.
  14. bandi

    bandi Hall Of Famer

    I went with Alex Smith...he's costing the niners a fortune and has proven he wasn't worth being a #1 draft pick.