Discussion in 'New York Giants' started by Saintsfan1972, May 29, 2007.
i had to ga ahead and vote yes
Yes, I say so.
For me he is a bust w/o waiting after the upcomming season
I think so, too.
I'm a huge Giants fan...and I think that this is really his make or break year, even with Sean Diehl as his left tackle. It took Peyton 3 years to really come into his own, hopefully Eli will pull it together and stop throwing off his backfoot every single damned time
Welcome to GIF JD, hope to see you posting in the football forums as well this season.
I agree that this is his make or break year. He starts out great then peeters out in the second half of the season, which is weird.
So Eli...how's that trade working out for you so far? :mrgreen:
thanks for your input dude, i was hoping to get some opinions from giants fans
I never thought he was #1 material. He only got there because of his name. He would have been a low 2nd, high 3rd rounder if he wasnt a Manning. I think he's a bust.
I have to vote yes by default because I think he's already a bust... and a cry baby. He should change his name to Eli Puddin' Cup and call it a day.
One 10 down, one more to go.
I'm giving Eli another year to determine wheather I think he's a bust or not. Appearlenty though when the Chargers had the #1 pick in the 2004 draft, Eli didn't think of the phrase "be careful what you ask for because you just might get it" and Eli has gotten it so far.
Separate names with a comma.