McNabb Vs. Bulger.......Who's Better

Discussion in 'NFL Smack Central' started by eaglesrule4ever, Mar 12, 2008.

  1. eaglesrule4ever

    eaglesrule4ever Pro Bowler

    mcnabb is way better than bulger alls i have to says wins count Actionjackson thats for sure you know hes better.
  2. Donavan McNabb

    3,732 ATT
    2,189 Completions
    58.7 Completion %
    25,404 Yards
    6.8 Avg per pass
    215.3 Yards a game
    171 TDs
    79 Int
    85.8 QB Rating.

    Marc Bulger

    2,484 Attempts
    1,578 Completions
    63.5 Completion %
    18,625 Yards
    7.5 Avg per pass
    258.7 Yards a game
    106 TDs
    74 Int
    88.1 QB Rating

    Marc Bulger has a better QB Rating, More Yards a game, better completion % and less Ints than McNabb
  3. SuperBeast

    SuperBeast BANNED

    Bulger has had 8 seasons

    Mcnabb- 10

    Bulger with 18,625 yrds, 106 tds and 74 pics

    Mcnabb with 25,404 yrds, 171 tds and 79 pics

    Playoff appearances isn't even close...Mcnabb in a landslide...

    averaging Bulgers #'s per season and adding them to his current #'s still has him falling short

    McNabb kicks the crap out of bulger......
  4. I'm afraid I have to disagree with your conclusion SuperBeast, McNabbs a douchebag
  5. SuperBeast

    SuperBeast BANNED

    take bulgers career #'s, average them, add them ( for two years) to give him 10 seasons ( same as Mcnabb)

    he still falls short

    but i will agree that both are douchebags
  6. Marc bulger has only played in 72 games while Mcnabb has played in 118, thats a difference of 46 games, and Marc Bulger didnt play his rookie year, and didnt start his sophmore year until Kurt got Hurt
  7. Ridin Burgundy

    Ridin Burgundy on the Magic Bandwagon

    Over his career yes, but now I would take Bulger.

    Doesn't really matter much though since neither can stay healthy.
  8. If Bulger would have played 118 games he would have 30,525 yards and 174 TDs
  9. 86WARD

    86WARD -

    I'd have to go with McNabb...he's had less to work with...a lot less.

    Na Brown
    Charles Johnson
    Torrance Small
    Todd Pinkston
    James Thrash
    Freddie Mitchell
    Antonio Freeman (the old version)
    Greg Lewis
    Billy McMullen
    Sean Morey
    Reggie Brown
    Darnarian McCants
    Hank Baskett
  10. Personally in my unbiased opinion, I would take Marc Bulger.

    He'd heck Donavan McNabb up in a street fight too if that matters at all
  11. SuperBeast

    SuperBeast BANNED

  12. Marion Who?

    Marion Who? Captain Stiff Arm

    Touche. :icon_lol:
  13. Dougerrrr

    Dougerrrr Laus Deo

    Warner> Both McNabb and Bulger

  14. Yes !!! Warner > Bulger > McNabb

    You must spread some Reputation around before giving it to Dougerrrr again
  15. eaglesrule4ever

    eaglesrule4ever Pro Bowler

    i'll say kurt warner is better but mcnabb with his skill and the running ability that he still has, Mcnabb has more skills,less weapons,better stats. Well in certain areas but does stats really mean anything, no wins do.
  16. so if wins are all that matter your saying...

    Trent Dilfer when on the Ravens > Dan Marino all time?
  17. Dougerrrr

    Dougerrrr Laus Deo

    Warner has a
  18. lol its no doubt that warner owns mcnabb, but this ER4E is claiming Donavan McNabb is a better QB because his TEAM wins more games..


  19. Brooklyn

    Brooklyn AKEKEKEKEKE!!!

    black > white