McNabb Vs. Bulger.......Who's Better

Discussion in 'NFL Smack Central' started by eaglesrule4ever, Mar 12, 2008.

  1. DawkinsINT

    DawkinsINT Tebow free since 9/5/2015.

  2. smeags

    smeags militant geek

    you have to be kidding, this is your arguement here ? knit picking a stat here and there ? you're gonna rip mcnabb for having FIVE more int's in 1248 more attempts ? are you serious ????

    take another look at that list of top notch, elite wr's mcnabb has had to work with over his career, are you really going to insult everyones intelligence by trying claim they were parallel to what bulger had ?
  3. 49erGenius

    49erGenius Banned

    McNabb is far more better.
  4. TheDuke

    TheDuke Breast Man

    Is this an actual post and is someone actually dylusional enough to take Bulger over McNabb? Even if I was a Felons fan i'd take McNabb over Bulger. Bulger is about as mobile as my bottle of contact solution and hasn't done jack crap in the NFL. McNabb=Playmaker.
    Bulger=QB who's had the benefit of having WR's who catch everything.

    End of point. Thrash, Pinkston, Mitchell, Charles Johnson..
    Holt and Bruce...

    Yeah, let's keep talking
  5. Bulger = Excellence
  6. 86WARD

    86WARD -


    I am hearing rumors that Trent Green "could" be competing for a starting job??
  7. eaglesrule4ever

    eaglesrule4ever Pro Bowler

    Just about everyone disagrees with you, man give it up!
  8. burnout2oo7

    burnout2oo7 I Am Dawk's Broken Heart

    McNabb has two capital letters, two b's, and rhymes with a crap load of words. Bulger is bulge with an r at the end. Case closed
  9. DoubleC

    DoubleC i'm ready now...

    Unbiased, huh? :doh:
  10. eaglesrule4ever

    eaglesrule4ever Pro Bowler

    MCNABB = Beat the crap of little butt white bulger!
  11. epinesett

    epinesett Special Teamer


    I agree, in Mcnabb prime he was a beast but now he is a lemon. If Bulger stay healthy he is the best right now (which is important to me).
  12. 86WARD

    86WARD -

    Present Day...all things being equal, I still take McNabb. Much more upside than Bulger.
  13. eaglesrule4ever

    eaglesrule4ever Pro Bowler

    He's telling the truth.
  14. 86WARD

    86WARD -

  15. Trent Dilfer > Donavan McNabb
  16. 86WARD

    86WARD -

    You just blew any hope you had for an argument with that craziness!!!

  17. smeags

    smeags militant geek

    291/473 - 61.5% - 3324yrds - 19td's - 7int's - 89.9qbr

    in only 14 games in what uneducated people call a horrible year. :icon_cool:
  18. andy82

    andy82 Your Soul, It's Mine!

    In determining the biggest cat out of the two, it's a very close call...
  19. mike oxlong

    mike oxlong The Voice Of Reason

    mcnabb has played 3 more seasons and only a few more picks while killing him in TD's.

    9 seasons to 6 seasons

    It comes down to Bulger has had guys like and including Holt, Bruce, Faulk, S-Jax his whole career basically.

    When D-Mac had TO, he was untouchable and beating Brees in stats when Brees was killing it 2 years ago.
    In '04 he had 31 TD's 8 Picks

    Bulger threw 15ints last year in only 12 games and 22 in his second year.

    Mcnabb has never thrown more than 13 (second season) and has also been at or close to 2TD's to 1 pick his entire career and has never thrown more picks than TD's in a season.

    Don't even get me started about how bulger plays mostly in a dome.