Top 5 At Each Position

fixed.

Roethlisberger is a tough leader and football player. But I don't base this on # of Super Bowl rings or women slept with (BURN!) Seriously, though, I just don't think he's a better QB than Manning, Brees, Rivers, Brady or Rodgers.

 

Dallas clark is defintely top 3 tight ends

 

lol...you let the hatred blind you...hater. Now if you would've said "women RAPED" that would be an attempt at a BURN! Not women slept with...lol...

 

hes better than rivers and rodgers....its not really a contest. he plays at an elite level with mediocre coaching and below mediocre blockers

hes not the greatest "passer" but he can move the ball down the field and hes definitely a top 5 QB and i love that people hate him so much because, yes, hes a douchebag

 

Same here and the fact that a portion of the hatred comes because he's a Steeler.

 

its all speculation but i mean put brady behind our line and put ben behind that brick wall and give him welker and moss and you get alot of wins from ben and alot of sacks for brady whos a way more traditional pocket passer. im saying ben is fast but hes nimble and so damn elusive and hard to bring down for a 6-5 250 pound guy

 

well the rapes are in dispute but the s*x isn't.

Come on. Seriously? You're telling me Mike McCarthy and Norv Turner are better coaches than Mike Tomlin? No waaaaaayyyyyyyyy. Also, Rodgers has a terrible line too. And Rivers matches Roethlisberger in toughness.

 

Seriously...Rivers and Rodgers aren't as good as Ben. It's a true story. It's almost not debatable - Let's talk about winning, clutch wins, come from behind wins, big wins. And for you to even leave him off the "honorable mention?" How do you explain that one?

 

Peters would make the top 10 at OT, not top 5,

I think it would be

Thomas
Long
Furgeson
Clady
Whitworth


Cedric Benson in the top 5 of RB is an utter joke. makes anything else listed not worth even reading

 

whitworth? give me a freaking break, brick was crap until faneca came around too. whitworth isnt even the 5th best in his own division....thomas, oher, gaither, starks and andre smith are/would all be better LTs. having whitworth in the top 5 LTs is criminal

 

im surprised at you K, I put whitworth because this isn't best pass blocking T, or run blocking T, it's overall and he may not blow you away in the pass game like long or thomas (Clady took a step back last year big time, and sucked against the run, wore down at the end of the year and I almost put whitworth ahead of him) or blow you away in the run game, like Thomas (See a trend) he does both well. Not many other T's can do both well. He really only had one bad game against minnesota, week 14. His biggest problems were early in the year with penalties. He only gave up 2 sacks after week 4 and only 5 QB hits after week 4.

While I would like to put Oher there, he didn't play enough at LT to solidify a top 5 spot yet. When he did, he struggled in the pass blocking more than I thought he would. His two worst games of the year were at LT. Week 6 against Minny and week 16 against Pitt, his pass blocking was downright terrible. I thought about Gaither, but he is no longer a LT, so even though he played VERY WELL at LT, I don't put RT's in my Top Tackles group.

I thought about Vollmer

 

dude well rounded isnt enough to be a top 5....hes not that good and having him on the list as top 5s is just pulling a pete prisco or peter king and going for the wow factor

 

oher was going against jared allen in that game and he more than held his own. wasn't his best game, but again, it was against allen.

 

yeah he had rough games against allen, harrison and woodley for his career total.....damn, 3 premier pass rushers and he wasnt even THAT bad


**********Automerged Doublepost**********

except woodley, woodley freaking KILLED him

 

like I said, this isn't best pass blocking T, or run blocking T, it's best T, Oher didn't play enough or well enough at T to make the list YET. Right now, that's how I see it.

 

This. I think Oher is GOING to be a Top 5 Level OT, he sint close yet, and probobly wont be quite as good as Long/Thomas/Clady

My Top 5 LT's in no order ( I dont think it is clear cut at all, and a very young group)

-Clady
-Thomas
-Long
-Fergeson
-Roos

 

ahhh...roos, good one


jordan gross is a good one too

 

I love Mayo but he's not Top 5 at his position. He's a good young linebacker and getting there, but he's not elite yet. I'd have EJ Henderson (if healthy) in the top 5.

 

fine, fair enough...hes definitely top 5 34 MLB then

 

QBs. 1. Drew Brees
2. Payton Manning
3. Aaron Rogers
4. Philip Rivers
5. Tom Brady


RBs. 1. CJ2k
2. all day
3. Frank Gore
4. Ronnie Brown
5. DeAngelo Williams and Jonathan Stewart



WRs. 1. Megatron
2. Andre Johnson
3.Larry Fitzgerald
4. Brandon Marshall
5. Roddy White



TEs. 1. Vernon Davis ( if he adds 50lbs... he could be the best tackle )
2. Jason Written
3. Antonio Gates
4. Tony Gonzalez
5. Brent Celek






thats the only positions i care about.