All Time NFL Quarterback Game

John Elway 7
Dan Marino 18
Joe Montana 19
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 17
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8 (+1)
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Joe Namath 3
Bart Starr 12 (-1)
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

Just so you guys know, the reason why it's important to use the (+/-1) format is because when we get down to 5 players left, we switch the amount of points given and taken away.

 

John Elway 7
Dan Marino 18
Joe Montana 19
Johnny Unitas 9 (+1)
Terry Bradshaw 17
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Joe Namath 2 (-1)
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

 

John Elway 7
Dan Marino 18
Joe Montana 19
Johnny Unitas 9 (+1)
Terry Bradshaw 17
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 12 (+1)
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Joe Namath 1 (-1)
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

 

John Elway 7
Dan Marino 19 (+1)
Joe Montana 19
Johnny Unitas 9
Terry Bradshaw 17
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 12
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Joe Namath 0 (-1)
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

 

John Elway 7
Dan Marino 19
Joe Montana 19
Johnny Unitas 8 -
Terry Bradshaw 18 +
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 12
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

 

John Elway 6 -
Dan Marino 20 +
Joe Montana 19
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 12
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

 

John Elway 6
Dan Marino 20
Joe Montana 20 +
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11 -
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 7

 

John Elway 6
Dan Marino 21 +1
Joe Montana 20
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 9
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6 -1

 

John Elway 6
Dan Marino 21
Joe Montana 21 (+1)
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11 (-1)
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

 

John Elway 6
Dan Marino 21
Joe Montana 21
Johnny Unitas 7 (-1)
Terry Bradshaw 19 (+1)
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

 

John Elway 6
Dan Marino 21
Joe Montana 21
Johnny Unitas 8 (+1)
Terry Bradshaw 18 (-1)
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

 

John Elway 5 - horse toothed bastard
Dan Marino 22 +
Joe Montana 21
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

 

John Elway 4 - horse toothed bastard
Dan Marino 23 +
Joe Montana 21
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

 

John Elway 4
Dan Marino 23
Joe Montana 21
Johnny Unitas 7 -
Terry Bradshaw 19 +
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

John Elway 4 (-1) (The most overrated qb ever?)
Dan Marino 22
Joe Montana 22 (+1) (Joe Cool.)
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 10
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 6

I skipped Nate's last post since the rules clearly state that one cannot follow oneself

 

John Elway 4
Dan Marino 22
Joe Montana 22
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 11
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 11 (+1)
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 5 (-1)

 

John Elway 4
Dan Marino 23 (+1)
Joe Montana 22
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 10 (-1)
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 11
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 5

 

John Elway 4
Dan Marino 24 (+1)
Joe Montana 22
Johnny Unitas 8
Terry Bradshaw 18
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 10
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 11
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 4 (-1)

 

this is all hecked up.

John Elway 4
Dan Marino 24 (+1)
Joe Montana 22
Johnny Unitas 7
Terry Bradshaw 20 +
Bob Griese 9
Roger Staubach 12
Troy Aikman 10
Steve Young 8
Fran Tarkenton 10
Warren Moon 11
Sid Luckman 10
Bart Starr 12
Dan Fouts 10
Joe Theisman 8
Len Dawson 10
Phil Simms 10
Jim Kelly 3 (-1)

i think its fixed now. walnuts skipped over the golden childs entry.