I don't see how anyone can justify Manning not deserving it. Sure some other people had a right to it also, but there wasn't much of a wrong choice.
I don't see how people can justify CJ winning it over Manning. They were 0-6 to begin with when he was playing and the Titans OL was ridiculous this year. He will get OPOY but its well deserved for Manning. There isn't one other QB that could do what he does for that team.
Take Peyton out of the Colts line-up and see what happens. They don't win more than 3 games this year. That's why he's the Most VALUABLE Player. Not the most explosive. Not the most dynamic. The word is VALUABLE.