What's Peyton Manning's Place In History If He Has To Retire Now?

Discussion in 'Indianapolis Colts' started by SRW, Sep 7, 2011.


Where Does Peyton Manning Land On Your All-Time Top QB List?

  1. #1 all time

    5 vote(s)
  2. #2 all time

    0 vote(s)
  3. #3 all time

    3 vote(s)
  4. #4 all time

    0 vote(s)
  5. #5 all time

    2 vote(s)
  6. Not in my top five all time

    4 vote(s)
  1. SRW

    SRW Ex-World's Worst Site Admin

    Great article this morning in the Washington Post from Michael Kun on what if the end is here for Peyton Manning. It got me wondering that Manning is definetly one of the all time best QB's. But where do our members rank him...and if he isn't #1, who is better than him and why?

    Check out the article: What if this is it for Peyton Manning? - The League - The Washington Post

    And feel free to pop your vote and comments. Here's my top 5:

    1. John Elway
    2. Johnny Unitas
    3. Peyton Manning
    4. Dan Marino
    5. Joe Montana
    Last edited: Sep 7, 2011
  2. Steve12

    Steve12 The night is dark and full of terrors

    Really interesting topic. I know I'm going to get blasted for being a homer, but here's my list.

    1A. Peyton Manning
    1B. Tom Brady
    3. John Elway
    4. Joe Montana
    5. Johnny Unitas

    I don't think Peyton's career is over. It would be a real shame if it is. The Colts have been the biggest rival of the Pats, and I hate the team. But I like and respect Peyton Manning as much, if not more than, any other player in the league.
  3. mike oxlong

    mike oxlong The Voice Of Reason

    in the top 5 definitely
  4. In the top 5 but not top 3
  5. Jihad Joe

    Jihad Joe Life to Infidels

    I have him at #5


    #1- Montana
    #2- Graham
    #3- Marino
    #4- Unitis
    #5- Manning
    #6- Elway
    #7- Brady
    #8- Farve
    #9- Young
    #10- Kelly
  6. Inclulbus

    Inclulbus WE ARE! .. Marshall!

    It's so hard, I put him as #1 though.

    #1 Manning
    #2 Marino
    #3 Montana
    #4 Elway
    #5 Favre
    #6 Kelly
    #7 Brady

    That's just me personally, from the quarterbacks I've actually had the chance of watching, especially seeing their entire career, or most of it.
  7. Sportsguy

    Sportsguy AKA-Sportsguy9695

    I would have to say he is # 5 on the list of all time quarterbacks